By

The short answer: the Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 is the best pro controller for most players. Microsoft’s own pad comes with paddles, extra thumbsticks and up to 40 hours per charge. If that’s more than you want to spend, PowerA and SCUF make officially licensed controllers with back buttons, usually priced below the Elite.

A pro controller adds back paddles (extra buttons under your fingers), trigger stops that shorten the trigger pull, and often thumbsticks that resist drift. Here are our picks, and what to check before you buy one for yourself or as a gift.

#1Best overall
Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 29.2Our
rating

Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2

Players who want Microsoft's own pro controller with every extra in the box.

  • ConnectionXbox Wireless, Bluetooth or USB-C
  • BatteryUp to 40 hours, built in
  • Back paddles4, included
  • Works withXbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Windows

Microsoft designed the Elite Series 2 with pro players. You can tighten or loosen the thumbsticks, and three-step hair trigger locks shorten how far the triggers travel. The box includes 6 thumbsticks, 4 paddles, 2 D-pads, a carrying case and a charging dock.

You set it up in the free Xbox Accessories app on an Xbox or Windows PC. Map the buttons, adjust dead zones (how far a stick moves before the game reacts) and save up to three profiles on the controller itself.

What we like

  • Paddles, extra thumbsticks, case and charging dock all in the box
  • Up to 40 hours of play per charge
  • Wireless, Bluetooth or USB-C on Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One, Windows PC and cloud
  • Headset jack

Watch out for

  • One of the most expensive controllers here
  • Microsoft doesn't describe its sticks as the magnetic kind that resist drift
Check price on Amazon Price band: $$$$
#2Best for shooters
SCUF Valor Pro Wired8.6Our
rating

SCUF Valor Pro Wired

Fast online shooters, where every split second counts.

  • ConnectionWired
  • Back paddles4, built in
  • TriggersInstant Triggers
  • SticksHall effect

SCUF builds four paddles into the back, and you can set them to up to 16 functions. Its Instant Triggers cut out the trigger pull, so a shot fires almost the moment you touch the trigger. The thumbsticks are the magnetic Hall effect kind.

A switch flips between three saved button setups, and you can change the volume from the controller. The faceplate and thumbsticks swap out, so it can get a new look later.

What we like

  • Four paddles built in, nothing to add
  • Instant Triggers for quick shots
  • Swappable faceplate and thumbsticks
  • Volume controls on the controller

Watch out for

  • Wired only: it plugs into the console with a cable
  • The listing doesn't say how long the cable is
Check price on Amazon Price band: $$$$
#3Best wireless for less
PowerA Wireless Controller (Hall effect)8.4Our
rating

PowerA Wireless Controller (Hall effect)

Wireless play with back buttons and magnetic sticks, usually priced below the Elite.

  • ConnectionWireless (USB adapter included)
  • BatteryRechargeable, up to 30 hours
  • Back buttons4
  • SticksHall effect

This officially licensed PowerA controller has Hall effect thumbsticks and triggers, which use magnets instead of parts that rub together. It adds four back buttons you can set mid-game, without going into any menus, plus three-way trigger locks and three profiles.

It plays wirelessly through a small USB adapter that comes in the box and plugs into the console. The free PowerA Gamer HQ app adjusts sound, triggers, rumble and dead zones.

What we like

  • Four back buttons and trigger locks
  • Hall effect sticks and triggers
  • Up to 30 hours per charge
  • Headset jack and three profiles

Watch out for

  • This edition wears Borderlands artwork, so check the photos suit the person
  • Wireless needs PowerA's USB adapter plugged into the console
Check price on Amazon Price band: $$$
#4Elite for less
Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 Core8.3Our
rating

Xbox Elite Wireless Controller Series 2 Core

Elite comfort and controls now, paddles later.

  • ConnectionXbox Wireless, Bluetooth or USB-C
  • BatteryUp to 40 hours, built in
  • Back paddlesNot included
  • In the boxController, cable, D-pad, 2 sticks, tool

The Core is the same Elite Series 2 controller, with the same adjustable thumbsticks, hair trigger locks, rubber grip and three profiles. The difference is the box: it comes with only a USB-C cable, one D-pad, two standard thumbsticks and an adjustment tool.

There are no paddles in the box. Microsoft sells them, with the case, dock and extra thumbsticks, as the Elite Series 2 Complete Component Pack. This listing is the red version.

What we like

  • The Elite's controls and up to 40 hours per charge
  • Paddles can be added later
  • Pick which color the Xbox button lights up

Watch out for

  • No paddles, case or charging dock in the box
  • Check the current prices of the Core plus the component pack against the full Elite before you choose
Check price on Amazon Price band: $$$$
#5Best wired with four back buttons
PowerA FUSION Pro 4 Wired Controller8.2Our
rating

PowerA FUSION Pro 4 Wired Controller

Players who don't mind a cable and want four back buttons and trigger locks.

  • ConnectionWired
  • Back buttons4
  • Trigger locks3 positions
  • SticksHall effect, adjustable height

PowerA's officially licensed FUSION Pro 4 has four back buttons you can program mid-game, without going into any menus. Three-way trigger locks set how far the triggers travel: short for quick shots, full for racing games.

Each Hall effect thumbstick twists between three heights. It also has rumble motors, rumble in the triggers and a headset jack.

What we like

  • Four back buttons
  • Three trigger-lock positions
  • Thumbstick height adjusts with a twist
  • Hall effect sticks

Watch out for

  • Wired only: the cable keeps you near the console
  • The listing doesn't mention saved profiles, which PowerA's wireless model has
Check price on Amazon Price band: $$$
#6Best budget pick
PowerA Advantage Plus Wired Controller8.0Our
rating

PowerA Advantage Plus Wired Controller

A first pro-style controller or a gift on a small budget.

  • ConnectionWired, 10 ft USB-C cable
  • Back buttons2
  • SticksHall effect, adjustable height
  • Warranty2-year limited

PowerA's officially licensed Advantage Plus brings two back buttons you can set mid-game, and Hall effect thumbsticks. Each stick's height twists between three settings, so you can try a taller stick without buying new parts.

It plugs in with an extra-long 10-foot USB-C cable and has a headset jack and rumble triggers. PowerA backs it with a two-year limited warranty.

What we like

  • Two back buttons at a budget price
  • Thumbstick height adjusts with a twist
  • Hall effect sticks
  • Two-year limited warranty

Watch out for

  • Wired only
  • Two back buttons, not four
  • The listing doesn't mention trigger locks
Check price on Amazon Price band: $$

What to look for

  • Back paddles or buttons. They copy buttons you already have, so you can jump or reload without taking your thumb off a stick. Two is a good start, and four suits shooters. For a controller you already own, see our add-on picks.
  • Trigger stops. Also called trigger locks. They shorten how far a trigger moves, so you can fire sooner. Racing games feel better with the full pull, so look for stops you can switch off.
  • Magnetic sticks (Hall effect or TMR). Makers say these wear less than standard sticks, which can “drift” over time and move your character on their own. Even makers stop short of a promise: PowerA says no technology can rule out every problem, and SCUF says magnetic sticks “don’t inherently fix drift.”
  • Wired or wireless. Wired controllers never need charging, but they keep you near the console. Several pro controllers here are wired only.
  • “Officially licensed” or “Designed for Xbox.” Every pick here says so. Unlicensed controllers can be blocked by the console after a two-week warning, according to Xbox Support; check Microsoft’s current policy.

Buying one as a gift

Check that the person plays on an Xbox Series X or S, an Xbox One or a Windows PC. Every pick here works with all three. Ask whether they mostly play shooters (paddles and trigger stops help most) or sports and racing games (comfort and battery life matter more). And keep the receipt and check the seller’s return policy. A custom controller from Xbox Design Lab is different: its FAQ says custom orders can’t be returned.

Warranties differ. In the US and Canada, Microsoft covers a standard Xbox controller for 90 days and the Elite Series 2 for one year. Microsoft’s warranty names the Elite Series 2 but not the Core edition, so check before you buy. PowerA says the Advantage Plus on this page comes with a two-year limited warranty. For more ways to make a controller your own, see our guide to custom Xbox controllers.

How we rate

We score every pick out of 10 on four things, weighted for what matters when you buy a controller, or an add-on for one: fits your console and your hands (35%), meaning the Xbox and PC models the maker says it works with, wired or wireless, and the grip and layout; build and how it holds up (30%), judged from the maker's specifications and warranty and the recurring praise and complaints in verified owners' reviews; features you will actually use (20%), like back paddles, trigger stops, swappable thumbsticks and battery life; and value (15%).

We have not tested these products ourselves. We read the makers' listings, compatibility notes and support pages, and the patterns in owners' reviews. No brand pays for placement, and a commission cannot buy a higher rating. When a pick changes, we will say so on this page.

How we choose products and make money

Common questions

Can back paddles get you banned?

No rule we found bans plain back paddles, which only repeat buttons you already have, and Microsoft makes the Elite Series 2 with four. Adapters are a different matter: Call of Duty’s anti-cheat team says it targets devices such as the Cronus Zen. Read what can get you banned before buying anything sold as “modded.”

Do pro controllers work on Xbox One?

Every controller on this page lists Xbox One as well as Xbox Series X|S and Windows. Check the box or listing for any other controller, because some work with an Xbox only through a cable.

Do these controllers need batteries?

The Elite Series 2, the Core and PowerA’s wireless pick have built-in rechargeable batteries. The wired picks (SCUF Valor Pro, FUSION Pro 4 and Advantage Plus) need no batteries at all, because they run through their cable.

Sources